• Home
  • About
    • Contact Danika
    • Help Your Kids Learn and Love the Bible
    • Who What Why Series | Christian Biographies for Kids
    • When Lightning Struck!: The Story of Martin Luther
    • Wonderfully Made: God’s Story of Life from Conception to Birth
    • Statement of Faith and Beliefs
    • Thinking Kids Disclosures
    • Thinking Kids Privacy Policy
    • Thinking Kids Website & Printables Terms and Conditions of Use
  • Thinking Kids Press Store
  • Help Your Kids Learn and Love the Bible
  • Who What Why Series | Christian Biographies for Kids
  • When Lightning Struck!
  • Wonderfully Made
  • Thinking Kids Press
    • Bible Road Trip™
      • Bible Road Trip™ Year One
      • 10 Reasons to Take a Road Trip Through the Bible
      • The Buzz on Bible Road Trip™ | Reviews
      • BRT ~ The Everything Page
      • Bible Verses for Children: Bible Road Trip™ Memory Verse Cards
      • Statement of Faith and Beliefs
    • Bible Lapbooks | Hands-On Bible Study for Kids
    • Cobblestone Path
  • Book Reviews
    • Parenting / Homeschooling
    • Ages 4-7
    • Middle Grade (Ages 8-12)
    • Middle School
    • High School
  • Christian Parenting
  • Homeschooling Coolness
  • Artfully Learned

Thinking Kids

Teach Your Kids the Bible and Christian History

Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

March 21, 2023 By Danika Leave a Comment

Thinking Kids Press uses referral links in posts. Signing up for free offers will subscribe you to our email list. We'll send you encouragement, free products, and exclusive offers via email. You can read our disclaimer, privacy policy, terms and conditions of use, and Danika Cooley's personal statement of faith and beliefs for more information. The Thinking Kids Press store is located at ThinkingKidsPress.com.
396 shares
  • Facebook143
  • Twitter

Looking for Easy Easter Cookies? Check out these sheep decorated Easter cookies with Bible verse gift tags you can print. A perfect project to do with kids!


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print


“I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep.” – John 10:11, ESV

The Lord uses a lot of word pictures–types and symbols–in His Word, the Bible. In his teaching, Jesus–God the Son, did the same. One of the symbols that comes up over and over again in Scripture is sheep.


Grab your FREE 130-page Bible Study Tool Kit--and learn about Help Your Kids Learn and Love the Bible!


When we read the Bible, we learn that Jesus is the Lamb of God–the sacrificial lamb that takes on the sins of the world, and dies for the forgiveness of all who believe in Jesus, confess their belief verbally, and repent of their sins. Helping kids understand the Lamb of God symbolism in Scripture is a wonderful way to teach about the doctrine of atonement in a way they can really grasp. Click here for a tool to help you teach about Jesus, the Lamb of God!


Bible Road Trip™ Teach Your Kid the Bible


The Bible also teaches that followers of Jesus are sheep. Jesus is the Good Shepherd who lays down his life for the sheep, protecting them from false teachings, and ushering them into his kingdom.


Take your kids through the Bible in just three years! Try out Bible Road Trip™ with a free three-week sample pack.


Teaching kids that Jesus is the Lamb of God, and that he is the Good Shepherd, are both really important concepts. What better time to cover both than Easter?

I don’t think there’s any better way to teach kids about the themes and symbolism of the Bible than to read the Bible. That’s the reason I wrote Bible Road Trip™–to help you go through Scripture as a family. That said, there are so many ways we can make learning about Scripture fun for our kids.

These sheep cookies are a fun way to talk about how believers in Christ are sheep. There are some cute printable tags with John 10:11 on them you can tie to the cellophane-wrapped sheep cookies. This easy Easter cookie project would be a fun gift to make a for neighbors, at Sunday school, or in a homeschool group.


Easy Decorated Easter Cookies

Check out this fun video I made of the Sheep Cookies!


Tips for Making Easter Cookies with Kids

Working on snack projects with kids is so much fun, but it can be a challenge. If you choose to involve your kids, I have a few suggestions for you.

  1. Expect a mess. Put your child’s long hair up, wash little hands, and have them wear washable clothes.
  2. Prepare the food before hand. For little ones, the real fun is in the decorating, so do as much of the prep work as you can before you involve the kids.
  3. Keep basic supplies on hand. I’m embarrassed to tell you how many types of sprinkles I have. We eat really healthy, but when we celebrate, there are always sprinkles involved. It’s nice to have a little supply of food decorations. You know, for emergencies.
  4. Set the food to be decorated on a child-size table or on a plastic table cloth on the floor. Nothing ruins the food decorating fun faster than having a child fall off a kitchen stool. Your kids will be intent on their decorating task. They may not remember they’re standing high above the ground. (Don’t ask me how many children fell off before I realized this!)
  5. It’s OK to do easy. For special celebrations, there’s nothing wrong with using store-made supplies!

 

Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

Gift Tags to Print

Sign up for the Thinking Kids newsletter, and you’ll receive encouragement, free gifts, and exclusive offers. Grab your FREE Good Shepherd gift tags (with the cookie instructions).

Free Button
Printing your gift tags:

  • Sometimes readers are concerned about using colored ink. If this is the case for you, there should be a setting on your printer that allows you to print in black and white. Printing in grayscale will still use some color, but it will come out prettier than black and white
  • I recommend printing on white cardstock so the cards will be more durable and the back won’t show through on the front. This is my very favorite cardstock: Neenah Premium Cardstock.
  • You’ll need to cut them out and glue them onto toothpicks. You can choose the black and white flags for your kids to color in, or the already colorful set.

Jesus the Lamb of God Bible Verses for Children
These cute Bible memory verse cards will teach your kids the doctrine of atonement!


Supplies Needed to Make Your Sheep Cookies

You’ll need a few supplies to make your project. You may have a few of these items already. If not, these are all fairly inexpensive and will serve you well for multiple projects.

 

Oreo Mega Stuf Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, 13.2 OunceOreo Mega Stuf Chocolate Sandwich CookiesOreo Mega Stuf Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, 13.2 OunceWilton Candy Melts, 12 oz.Wilton Candy Melts, 12 oz.Wilton Candy Melts, 12 oz.Wilton Black Candy Melts, 10-OunceWilton Black Candy Melts, 10-OunceWilton Black Candy Melts, 10-OunceKraft Jet Puffed Mallow Bits, Vanilla, 3 ozKraft Jet Puffed Mallow Bits, Vanilla, 3 ozKraft Jet Puffed Mallow Bits, Vanilla, 3 ozCK Products Non-Pareils White, 3.8 Oz.CK Products Non-Pareils White, 3.8 Oz.CK Products Non-Pareils White, 3.8 Oz.Confetti Jumbo Red Hearts 2.8 oz. CONJRHConfetti Jumbo Red Hearts 2.8 oz. CONJRHConfetti Jumbo Red Hearts 2.8 oz. CONJRHBamboo Wooden ToothpicksBamboo Wooden ToothpicksBamboo Wooden ToothpicksNeenah Cardstock, 8.5Neenah Cardstock, 8.5Neenah Cardstock, 8.5Fiskars 01-004761J Softgrip Scissors Straight Stainless Steel, 8 InchFiskars 01-004761J Softgrip Scissors Straight Stainless Steel, 8 InchFiskars 01-004761J Softgrip Scissors Straight Stainless Steel, 8 InchFiskars 23517097J Circle Hand Punch, 1/8 Inch, PurpleFiskars 23517097J Circle Hand Punch, 1/8 Inch, PurpleFiskars 23517097J Circle Hand Punch, 1/8 Inch, Purple

  • 1 package Double Stuf Oreo Chocolate Sandwich Cookies
  • 2 (11 ounce) packages white chocolate chips or candy melting wafers
  • 1 (10 ounce) package black candy melting wafers
  • 1 (3 ounce) container vanilla marshmallow bits
  • White nonpareil sprinkles
  • Heart sprinkles
  • Good Shepherd gift tags
  • Scissors
  • Hole Punch

Creating Your Decorated Easter Cookies

Before you get started on the cookies, read John 10:11-15 with your kids.

Talk about how Jesus is the Good Shepherd, who lays down his life for the sheep. Talk about what it means that Jesus laid down his life for us–so that our sins can be forgiven, and about how he rose from the dead. One day, the Good Shepherd will return for his sheep!

Here are the steps for your Easter sheep cookie assembly:


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

1) Print Your Good Shepherd Gift Tags.

Print out your gift tags in the version of your choice (ESV or KJV). Use cardstock to make them durable. You can print as many sheets as you’d like!


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

2) Cut Out Your Gift Tags and Punch a Hole in the Top of Each.

Cut out your gift tags and use a hole punch to make a hole in the top of each one.


3) Line Your Baking Sheet.

Line your baking sheet with wax paper to protect it.


4) Heat Your White Chocolate Chips.

Place white chocolate chips in a microwave safe bowl. You’ll just want to heat one bag at a time. Heat on high for 30 seconds and stir. Repeat in 30-second increments, stirring each time, until completely melted. Do not overheat as the chocolate will seize and become unusable. If the chocolate is too thick to pour, you can add coconut oil or vegetable shortening to the chocolate, 1 teaspoon at a time, until you reach a pourable consistency.


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

5) Coat Your Cookie with White Chocolate.

Drop cookie into melted chocolate and turn to coat completely. Place cookie in a fork, tapping the fork gently against the side of the bowl, allowing excess chocolate to return to the bowl. If air bubbles form, pop them with a toothpick.


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

6) Put Marshmallows on Your Cookie.

Slide the coated cookie onto the baking sheet. Using a clean piping tip to protect the middle of the cookie, sprinkle marshmallow bits over the cookie and press into place. Remove the piping quickly with a slight twist. Allow cookies to set completely before proceeding to the next step.


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

7) Make Your Sheep’s Face.

Melt black candy melts according to package directions. Transfer to a piping bag or zip-top freezer bag with the corner snipped. Pour candy into the middle of the cookie to create the sheep face.


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

8) Give Your Sheep a Candy Face.

While the candy is wet, use sterilized tweezers and/or a toothpick to place the white nonpareils as eyes and a heart as the snout.


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

9) Wrap Each Cookie in Cellophane.

Allow cookie to set completely at room temperature or refrigerate for faster results. Wrap each cookie in colored cellophane, tie a ribbon around the top.


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

10) Attach the Gift Tag to Your Cookies.

Thread one end of your ribbon through a Bible verse gift tag and make a bow.


Easter Books for Your Family

The Third Day: The Gospel of Luke 22-24The Third Day: The Gospel of Luke 22-24The Third Day: The Gospel of Luke 22-24The World Created, Fallen, Redeemed, and Restored: The Gospel Plan of GodThe World Created, Fallen, Redeemed, and Restored: The Gospel Plan of GodThe World Created, Fallen, Redeemed, and Restored: The Gospel Plan of GodThe Easter Story: The Bible VersionThe Easter Story: The Bible VersionThe Easter Story: The Bible VersionMy Easter Activity Book: 40 Days to Celebrate Jesus’ ResurrectionMy Easter Activity Book: 40 Days to Celebrate Jesus’ ResurrectionMy Easter Activity Book: 40 Days to Celebrate Jesus’ ResurrectionJesus: The Best Story (Board Book)Jesus: The Best Story (Board Book)Jesus: The Best Story (Board Book)


Books Make Great Gifts!

Help Your Kids Learn and Love the BibleHelp Your Kids Learn and Love the BibleHelp Your Kids Learn and Love the BibleWho was Martin Luther? (Who What Why)Who was Martin Luther? (Who What Why)Who was Martin Luther? (Who What Why)What was the Gutenberg Bible? (Who What Why)What was the Gutenberg Bible? (Who What Why)What was the Gutenberg Bible? (Who What Why)Why did the Reformation Happen? (Who What Why)Why did the Reformation Happen? (Who What Why)Why did the Reformation Happen? (Who What Why)When Lightning Struck!: The Story of Martin LutherWhen Lightning Struck!: The Story of Martin LutherWhen Lightning Struck!: The Story of Martin LutherWonderfully Made: God’s Story of Life from Conception to BirthWonderfully Made: God’s Story of Life from Conception to BirthWonderfully Made: God’s Story of Life from Conception to Birth


Help Your Kids Learn and Love the Bible

Looking for a family discipleship book that will give you a crash course in leading your kids through God’s Word? I’ve got you covered.

Love the Bible for Kids | A resource you'll love!

You want your kids to learn and love the Bible. 

You want to teach the Bible…

As parents, we deeply desire the best for our kids. We look for the right schools, we make them eat right and exercise, and we get them involved in extracurricular activities. We take our job as parents seriously.

But are we also putting our time and energy into
teaching them the Bible? Giving them the life-changing, soul-nourishing words of Scripture is not only doable, it’s an essential part of parenting kids for Jesus. And the good news is, studying God’s Word as a family doesn’t have to be difficult!

2 Timothy 2:15, ESV, says:

Do your best to present yourself to God as one approved,
a worker who has no need to be ashamed, rightly handling the word of truth.

Our job, as parents who love Jesus, is to help our kids become approved workers, unashamed and rightly handling the word of truth.

The good news? Teaching the Bible isn’t hard. Your family can learn the Bible together.

…and you can!

A Crash Course in Teaching the Bible to Your Kids

Danika Cooley’s book, Help Your Kids Learn and Love the Bible, will give you the tools and confidence to study the Bible as a family. It will help you identify and overcome your objections and fears, give you a crash course in what the Bible is all about and how to teach it, and provide the guidance you need to set up a family Bible study habit.

You will finish this book feeling encouraged and empowered to initiate and strengthen your child’s relationship with the Lord through His Word.

Help Your Kids Learn and Love the Bible button

Help Your Kids Learn and Love the Bible will equip you with everything you need to know to teach the Bible to your kids!

Tauna Meyer Help Your Kids Learn and Love the Bible 3


Reformation Family Book Bundle
Your kids will love the Who What Why Reformation series with illustrated narratives for 8-11 year olds.
And, Martin Luther’s young adult historical fiction story makes the perfect family read aloud!
Grab the autographed Reformation Family Bundle!


More Thinking Kids Posts You’ll Love!

Bible Road Trip™ Three Year CurriculumLove the Bible for Kids | A resource you'll love!Who What Why Christian History SeriesWonderfully Made: God's Story of Life from Conception to BirthWhen Lightning Struck!: The Story of Martin Luther10 Reasons to Take a Road Trip Through the BibleCross lampeaster activitiesResurrection LapbookbookmarksLEGOLamb of GodEmpty Tomb ClayrollsEaster wreathresurrection versesempty tomb cupcakesEaster bookssheep cookieseaster seasongamehopecross crispiesJesus istreatsgraphic novelcraftsforgivenessthe easter storyfaithactivity bookSpiritual Disciplines Calendar for KidsBible Lapbooks | Hands-On Bible Study for KidsFun Printable Bible Activities for KidsDaily Devotions for Kids | A 12-Month Bible Verse Calendar for your FamilyBible fun and memorableWho What Why Reformation Free Printable LapbooksThe Right Age to Teach Your Children the BibleThe Bible is a Storyteach about the bible5 Things That Occur When I Complain about My KidIntentional Christian Parenting TipsRead through the Biblebible bannerStudy BibleCreation Crafts and ActivitiesStewarding Talents and Spiritual Gifts in Your Children5 Parenting Questions to Ask YourselfBible is a storyTeaching Christian Worldview to Your Children in a Way They'll UnderstandBible lapbookBest Bible Verses for Your Family to MemorizeDaily Bible readingBible puppetsCalm the Angry Parent Inside and Build Your Kids UpRainbow Bible Arts and Crafts for KidsHow to Study the Bible for KidsBible comic stripTeach Kids the BibleArmor of God Crafts and Activitieslet go of perfection in Bible studybooks bible posterround robin biblecheat sheetstough questions bibleGeneration Biblebooks Bible bookmarksBible activitiesBible Reading chartfamily Bible studyfamily discipleshipgospel bible versesBooks of the Bible Activitiesverses about the BibleTrain up


Decorated Easter Sheep Cookies with Gift Tags to Print

Join the newsletter

Get the Family Prayer Box Project FREE!

Teach your children to pray with this fun project that includes 7 printable sets!

Awesome! Go check your email to confirm your subscription. After you confirm, I'll send your Family Prayer Box Project!

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit

Filed Under: Artfully Learned, Christian Parenting, Subscriber Freebies

Join the Newsletter and Get Gifts and Offers

« Christian Easter Cross Rice Crispy Treats
28 Easter Crafts for Kids who Love Jesus »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

photo credit: @billdjohnson

Welcome to Thinking Kids!

My name is Danika Cooley, and I’m glad you’re here. This site exists to help equip you to teach your kids the Bible and Christian history. I’m an author, a homeschool mom, and a curriculum developer. Pull up a chair and stay awhile.

Get Gifts & Exclusive Offers

Danika Cooley | As Seen and Heard On
Love the Bible for Kids | A resource you'll love!
10 Reasons to Take a Road Trip Through the Bible
Who What Why Reformation Free Printable Lapbooks

Popular Posts

How to Read the Bible using Round Robin Reading

How to Read the Bible with Kids using Round Robin Reading

The Ology by Marty Machowski | Theology for Kids

The Ology by Marty Machowski | Theology for Kids

How to Study the Bible in Context | Two Great Books for Kids!

How to Study the Bible in Context | Two Great Books for Kids!

Picture Books about the Minor Prophets of the Bible

Picture Books about the Minor Prophets of the Bible

Copyright 2010-2019 Danika Cooley.

About page images © Pam Koch 2015. Headshot © Bill D. Johnson 2015.
396 shares

Teaching history? 
Register now
for the FREE, online
God-Centered History Summit!
×